Once an acquisition is in your accounts, the goodwill and indefinite-life brands from the purchase price allocation must be tested for impairment at least once a year. The test turns on forecasts, discount rates and judgement, which is where external auditors ask the most questions. For UAE and GCC groups we prepare goodwill and intangible impairment tests under IAS 36 and ASC 350, with models that can be rolled forward each year.
What goodwill impairment testing is
Under full IFRS, goodwill is not amortised. Instead, IAS 36 Impairment of Assets requires a test that checks the carrying amount is not more than what can be recovered.
- Cash-generating units (CGUs). Goodwill is allocated to the CGU, or group of CGUs, expected to benefit from the synergies of the acquisition, and no larger than an operating segment. The test runs at that level.
- Recoverable amount. The higher of value in use, which is the present value of the cash flows from continuing to use the unit, and fair value less costs of disposal, which is the price a market participant would pay, less the costs of selling.
- Impairment. If the carrying amount exceeds the recoverable amount, the difference is an impairment loss. It reduces goodwill first, then the other assets of the unit pro rata. A goodwill impairment is never reversed.
Under US GAAP, ASC 350 compares the fair value of a reporting unit with its carrying amount in a single quantitative step, after an optional qualitative assessment. Any excess of carrying amount is the impairment, capped at the goodwill of the unit. Private companies may instead elect to amortise goodwill, usually over ten years or less, and test it only when there is a trigger.
When you need one
- Every year for goodwill, indefinite-life intangibles and intangibles not yet available for use. The test can be done at any time in the year, as long as it is the same time each year. Goodwill from an acquisition made during the year must be tested before that year ends.
- Whenever there is a trigger, such as:
- results well below the plan used at acquisition - the loss of a major customer, contract or licence - higher interest rates that raise the discount rate - a market capitalisation below net assets for a listed group - a restructuring, disposal or change in how the business is managed
- For other assets such as property, equipment and finite-life intangibles, when there is an indication of impairment.
Our approach and methods
1. Set the units correctly. We confirm the CGU or reporting unit structure against how management monitors the business. The choice of units is a frequent point of challenge.
2. Build the cash flows. Value in use must reflect the asset in its current condition. That means excluding future restructurings that are not yet committed and enhancements not yet made. Detailed forecasts normally cover no more than five years unless a longer period can be justified. We test the forecast against past accuracy and explain any break from history.
3. Set the discount rate. IAS 36 states value in use on a pre-tax basis. Most groups model post-tax cash flows in practice, so we build the rate from market data, show the bridge to the pre-tax rate, and reflect country, size and business-specific risks. For UAE units, tax cash flows use the 9% corporate tax rate, plus any Pillar Two top-up tax a group in scope expects to pay.
4. Cross-check. We compare value in use with market multiples and recent transactions, and for listed groups reconcile the total to market capitalisation.
5. Run sensitivities. IAS 36 asks for disclosure of key assumptions and, where a reasonably possible change would cause an impairment, how much headroom there is. We size that headroom for each key input.
Common challenges from external auditors
- Forecasts that beat history. A plan that grows much faster than past results needs a clear reason, such as signed contracts or a new product already selling.
- A terminal growth rate above the long-term outlook for the market or the economy the unit trades in.
- Discount rates copied from last year without updating market data, or a mix of pre-tax and post-tax inputs.
- Corporate costs left out. Head office costs that support the unit should be allocated to it.
- Thin headroom with thin disclosure. Where a small change in one input would cause a write-off, IAS 36 expects the sensitivity to be disclosed.
We address each of these in the file before review starts.
The UAE corporate tax angle
UAE corporate tax starts from accounting profit, so an impairment charge appears in the starting figure. The tax treatment of a goodwill impairment is not yet specifically addressed in FTA guidance, so take advice before relying on a deduction. Where goodwill came from a share deal, it sits only in the consolidated accounts, which also limits any effect on a standalone return. See PPA and UAE corporate tax.
What you receive
- An impairment test report for each CGU or reporting unit
- A recoverable amount or fair value with the method and key assumptions explained
- The discount rate build, with sources
- Sensitivity and headroom analysis ready for your disclosure note
- Draft wording for the key assumptions disclosure
- A model you can roll forward next year, and support through your external auditors' review
Timeline
Most groups run the test close to year-end, which is also when external auditors are busiest. We recommend setting the test date a few weeks before year-end, so the approved budget is available and the file is ready before fieldwork. The time needed depends on the number of units and the state of the forecasts. A roll-forward of a model we built last year is faster than a first test.
Why iConsult
- Listed and private groups. Our team has prepared impairment tests for listed groups and private equity portfolios under IFRS and US GAAP.
- Team experience, including prior roles at a Big 4 firm. Goodwill impairment testing across industrial portfolio companies for AEA Investors. Goodwill impairment testing of global media assets for News Corp.
- Joined up with the PPA. We also prepare purchase price allocations, so the assumptions at acquisition and at each test stay consistent.
- Founded in Dubai in 1975, working with UAE and international groups.
Read why IFRS 3 requires a PPA, or return to valuation services.
Book a free consultation to plan this year's impairment test.